Books news, reviews and author interviews | guardian.co.uk

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Diary Entry by Nick

Recently, I’ve had a rendezvous for a lunch at the city with Gatsby and one of his friends, Meyer Wolfshiem. The lunch was rather interesting as parts of our conversation stuck in my mind and played with my knowledge about certain things. It made me question myself, who this ‘Gatsby’ really is… And coming from such a small place; I’d rather say New York business is wrongly fascinating.

Thinking back to when I first met Meyer Wolfshiem that day, I wasn’t expecting him to create further chaos in my head as I was already quite frustrated with Gatsby comments involving Jordan. I was already prepared to confront Gatsby and discuss about it when Wolfshiem decided to spatter around his little stories – which did interest me quite a bit. I’d like to believe I’m always interested in sincere and up-to-the-minute stories as they open my mind to new doors. Therefore, Meyer Wolfshiem stories were, I suppose, emotional. I presume old men get emotional easily as aging hits their sensitive part a little. His story about Rosen Rosenthal particularly caught my attention –besides other things. I mean, this man was shot several times on the chest and the murderers never got caught… And for over what reason did he die for? This story shocked me inside. I know Rosy Rosenthal was a business man for a fact – Wolfshiem must have mentioned it. And this made me realize how dangerous business is in the East until I found out another thing. Wolfshiem was involved in the fixing of the World Series. I never really thought how such an individual could have the power to do something likewise and not be in prison. Are policemen or the government security even at their jobs these days or are they just laying there kissing feet of the rich, wishing they were in their shoes. That could possibly be a fact. Wolfshiem and his little nose, bizarre and influential man he is; makes me think that money does mean power. I kept in mind his saying about how money shut a man right up – this just proves today’s hunger for wealth. And it is a sad thing…is it…

But for a man with so much power, Meyer Wolfshiem is ignorant. He kept blabbering on about some sort of Oggsford which I am certain he meant Oxford and I’ve noticed many grammar gaps in his English. Yes, Gatsby, I thought, smart man he truly is!

However, other things concerned me more and indeed, it is about Gatsby. He was not acting tout-a-fait normal. He seemed a little uncomfortable; possibly because he was worried I wasn’t comfortable myself. Though, I think because I was about to hear something which have made me question what really is Gatsby’s past; has he been lying to me from the start of our friendship? I know as a truth that Gatsby told me himself that he was from a very rich family and his wealth was inherited. However Meyer Wolfshiem story was far from similar. It was quite upsetting when I heard that he was actually a poor boy who created his wealth by himself. And for I to know that Gatsby and Wolfshiem had business ‘connections’, I knew at that moment Gatsby was involved in illegal business. I haven’t really thought about how I felt about Gatsby being a fraud with the giant amount of respect I have for him. But then I recalled my father’s advice, on how some people did not have the advantages that other people had and it made me reflect. If what Meyer Wolfshiem said was true, then I’d accept it. Gatsby struggled and had no choice but to go through what he did in order to reach to a good state. But are there other reasons to it? However, my acceptance of Gatsby does not reach the conclusion to my curiosity of him. If Gatsby lied about his background, what else have he lied about? Everything I know about him and the time I have spent with him could all be just fiction or an act – an appealing act though. Who is this person hiding behind his wealth and what is he living for.

The lunch became even more gauche when I had an encounter with Tom. I couldn’t help myself to be offended when he mentioned how was able to get here but I controlled my judgments quite well but that wasn’t what bothered me the most. It was Gatsby again, gone out of the blue just a little bit after I introduced him to town. It was supposedly like Gatsby couldn’t stand Tom’s presence or he has heard of Tom before. This made me think even harder about what Gatsby’s past was like and the intensity of my curiosity hasn’t yet died till this day.

18 comments:

  1. I like how you elaborated your thoughts well.

    But...I thought Wolfsheim's nose was supposed to be enormous.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "I’d like to believe I’m always interested in sincere and up-to-the-minute stories as they open my mind to new doors. Therefore, Meyer Wolfshiem stories were, I suppose, emotional. I presume old men get emotional easily as aging hits their sensitive part a little."

    Nick's contradictions and dishonesty is shown well here.

    ReplyDelete
  3. haha thanks you guys

    and yeah i dont know
    policutt said woldshiem was a jew
    and i met a jew this summer
    and he had a small and pointy nose.

    ReplyDelete
  4. i think polli also said that back then jews stereotypically had big noses and that was what Nick was focusing on because it fitted the stereotype and that shows his racism.

    ReplyDelete
  5. AHHAHAHAAHHA

    and i met a jew this summer
    and he had a small and pointy nose.

    and i met a jew this summer
    and he had a small and pointy nose.

    and i met a jew this summer
    and he had a small and pointy nose.

    and i met a jew this summer
    and he had a small and pointy nose.

    and i met a jew this summer
    and he had a small and pointy nose.

    hahahahaha omggg ba dien

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey guys!

    Is the fact that Wolfshiem is a Jew and he has big nose really significant that we need to mention to emphasise his 'devil' and the unexpected relationship between Gatsby and Wolfshiem? :D

    ReplyDelete
  7. mentioning it emphasises on Nick's racism and how he focuses on the nose because it tells you that he's a jew

    i think lien's on drugs

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh wow!!! I didn't know that Nick was affected by racism too! >.< I thought only Tom was! Thank you, Sophiaaaaaa!!!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I don't think s/he is in our class! >.<

    ReplyDelete
  10. True! -.-' omg... Sorry Ashley!!! I didn't mean to exclude you! :(
    Btw, I find it very hard to assess our entries :( So many aspects to look at! Mr.Pollicutt's marking is very highly appreciated now!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Uyen, Assessment Foci are up and I'm getting around to marking all your work. (see first page of blog).

    Be careful with some of the comments guys- some of you are sounding a little anti- semitic yourselves.

    Lien- have a lie down.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Mytam, I like your opening paragraph - the use of the almost oxymoronic phrase "wrongly fascinating" is very Nick-esque and I would have liked to have seen such opposing language throughout to reflect Nick's conflicted thoughts.

    Despite some rather clumsy expressions where I feel you rather lose the authenticity of Nick's voice, unlike many others, you DO succeed in bringing in some of the novel's wider themes into Nick's thoughts about the lunch date (e.g truth/ lies, the link between death and business in the east). This could have been done even more BUT I am glad that you did do it because it just puts you up into Band 1 (A grade) territory.

    I'm not sure what a man's "sensitive part" is though...(!)

    ReplyDelete
  13. lol a man sensitive part
    is when they get emotional.
    as you grow older you think more about your lfie and stuff like that
    you get less carefree and you get emotional
    thats why i think


    that means i got an A?>??????'
    Omg :D

    ReplyDelete
  14. im not anti semetic btw
    the jew i met was quite good looking

    ReplyDelete
  15. HAHAha
    Mytam said...

    im not anti semetic btw
    the jew i met was quite good looking
    LIKE.

    i like yours too :D
    firstly, i like how this essay does not only revolve around Gatsby.You show jealousy when talking about Jordan, sympathy with Wolfshiem; Hits his sensitive part,resentment to the government and to the poor- when he is upset not about the bussiness gonnegtion but that Gatsby is poor
    i think it reveals even more about Nick when you say ;I kept in mind his saying about how money shut a man right up – this just proves today’s hunger for wealth. And it is a sad thing…is it…
    because Nick is actually in between the rich and the poor, and so he can think from a snobby point of view and also a more humble, sympathetic one.
    he also does invest alot of curiousity and time thinking about Gatsby and the mystery that surrounds him which i liked because he tries to deny that these things absorb him but he lets his true feelings out in this diary

    ReplyDelete